⚖️ The Path to Redress: Waitangi Tribunal & Modern Settlements
🎯 Learning Objectives
Students will be able to:
- Explain the role and significance of the Waitangi Tribunal in addressing historical injustices
- Analyze the connection between 1970s activism and the creation of formal redress mechanisms
- Evaluate the strengths and limitations of the Treaty settlement process
- Synthesize learning from the entire unit into a coherent narrative of Māori resistance and sovereignty
📚 Key Concepts
- Waitangi Tribunal (1975): Established to hear Treaty grievances - direct result of activism
- Treaty Settlements: Financial and symbolic redress for historical wrongs
- Wai Reports: Tribunal investigations into specific claims (e.g., Wai 11: Te Reo Māori report)
- Partial Justice: Settlements acknowledge harm but can never fully restore what was lost
- Ongoing Struggle: Redress is progress, but tino rangatiratanga remains incomplete
🚀 Lesson Structure
Part 1: Reading & Discussion - Waitangi Tribunal (25 minutes)
Resources: Waitangi Tribunal Cases Handout · Lesson 5 Source Pack
Purpose: Understand how activism led to institutional change.
Activity:
- Read Together (10 min): Distribute handout. Read about:
- Establishment (1975): Created after Land March - direct concession to protest pressure
- Wai 11 (1986): Te Reo Māori report - declared te reo a "taonga" under Treaty protection
- Ngāi Tahu (1991): Major South Island claim, $170M settlement (though land value far higher)
- Discussion Questions (15 min):
- "How is the Waitangi Tribunal connected to Lesson 4's activism?" (Protests forced government to create formal process)
- "What does the Te Reo report tell us about the Treaty?" (Not just about land - about culture, language, survival)
- "Are settlements 'enough'? Can money fix historical trauma?" (Complex - acknowledge without erasing ongoing harm)
💡 Teaching Tip: Students may think settlements "solved" everything. Push back - settlements are partial justice, not full restoration. The struggle continues.
Part 2: Unit Synthesis - Timeline/Mind Map (30 minutes)
Purpose: Connect all five lessons into one coherent story of resistance and agency.
Activity:
- Create Visual (20 min): As a class or in groups, create a large timeline or
mind map showing:
- Pre-Colonial (L1): Sophisticated societies with advanced technology and governance
- Aotearoa Wars (L2): Strategic military resistance to land theft
- 20th Century (L3): Urbanization, discrimination, and ongoing marginalization
- Activism (L4): Fire of 1970s protest - Land March, Bastion Point, Ngā Tamatoa
- Redress (L5): Waitangi Tribunal, settlements, partial justice
- Add Connections: Draw arrows or lines showing:
- Land confiscation (L2) → urban migration (L3) → concentrated activism (L4)
- Activism (L4) → political pressure → Tribunal created (L5)
- Throughout: Tino rangatiratanga as the constant demand
- Whole-Class Reflection (10 min): "What's the big story of this unit? What
connects all these events?"
- Answer: Māori never stopped fighting for sovereignty. From pre-colonial governance → military resistance → modern activism → legal/political redress. Same struggle, different tactics.
Part 3: Assessment Introduction (15 minutes)
Purpose: Launch the summative assessment - decolonized historical essay.
Activity:
Introduce the unit assessment: Students will write a historical essay using a decolonized framework, centering Māori agency and resistance. Essay prompt:
Essay Prompt:
"How have Māori fought for tino rangatiratanga from the 19th century to today? Analyze at least TWO historical periods/events from this unit to show continuity in the struggle for sovereignty."
Introduce Success Criteria:
- Thesis centers Māori agency (not victimization)
- Evidence from at least two lessons
- Analysis of strategies, not just description
- Connections to tino rangatiratanga as throughline
- Counter-narrative approach (challenges colonial framing)
Handout Resources:
Part 4: Exit Reflection (5 minutes)
Prompt: "What's the most important thing you learned in this unit? How has your understanding of Aotearoa history changed?"
Optional Add-On: "What questions do you still have?"
📊 Assessment
Formative: Timeline/mind map contributions, discussion participation, exit reflection
Summative: Decolonized historical essay (to be completed over next 1-2 weeks)
🎓 Teacher Notes
Preparation:
- Print Waitangi Tribunal handout
- Prepare large chart paper/whiteboard for timeline/mind map
- Have markers in multiple colors for connections
- Print essay prompt and success criteria for students to take home
Differentiation:
- Support: Provide pre-made timeline with dates. Students add events and connections. For essay, provide sentence starters and thesis templates.
- Core: Standard activities as described
- Extension: Students research a current Treaty settlement (e.g., Waikato-Tainui, Ngāi Tūhoe) and present to class
Emotional Landing:
- This unit covers heavy material - acknowledge the emotional labor
- End on hope: resistance continues, progress is real (even if incomplete)
- Frame assessment as opportunity to honor the stories learned
- Thank students for engaging with difficult history with care
🔗 Connections to NZC
- Social Studies Level 5: Understand how people view and use places differently
- History Level 6: Understand how historical forces and movements have influenced the lives of people and caused change
- Key Competencies: Thinking (synthesis, critical analysis), Participating and Contributing (understanding civic processes)
➡️ Next Steps
For Students: Begin working on decolonized historical essay. Use framework from this unit to analyze Māori resistance and agency.
For Teachers: Provide feedback on essay drafts. Consider bringing in Māori community members to share contemporary perspectives on Treaty settlements and tino rangatiratanga.