🔍 Year 8 Critical Thinking

NZ History Investigation Toolkit

Te Pūtake Rangahau Hītori o Aotearoa

📖 About This Toolkit

New Zealand's history is rich, complex, and often told from different perspectives. As critical thinkers, we need tools to investigate historical sources, understand multiple viewpoints, and form our own informed conclusions.

"Kia whakatōmuri te haere whakamua"

"I walk backwards into the future with my eyes fixed on my past"

— This whakataukī reminds us that understanding where we come from helps us move forward wisely.

🗂️ Tool 1: Understanding Source Types

Historical evidence comes in many forms. Each type has strengths and limitations:

📜 Primary Sources

Created at the time of the event

  • Letters, diaries, journals
  • Photographs, maps
  • Treaty documents
  • Oral histories (pūrākau)
  • Newspapers from the time
  • Whakapapa records

✓ Direct evidence from the time

✗ May be biased; limited perspective

📚 Secondary Sources

Created later, analysing past events

  • History books, textbooks
  • Documentaries
  • Museum displays
  • Academic articles
  • Te Ara encyclopedia entries
  • Historical websites

✓ Analysis and context provided

✗ Shaped by author's interpretation

🎭 Māori Sources

Traditional and contemporary Māori knowledge

  • Whakapapa (genealogy)
  • Pūrākau (traditional narratives)
  • Waiata (songs)
  • Kōrero tuku iho (oral traditions)
  • Tā moko designs
  • Place names (ingoa wāhi)

✓ Indigenous perspective; deep history

✗ Some knowledge is tapu/restricted

🔎 Tool 2: The WITNESS Framework

Use these questions to analyse any historical source:

W
Who created this?

What do we know about the author? What was their background, position, or role?

I
Intent — Why was it created?

To record? To persuade? To justify? For official purposes? For personal memory?

T
Time — When was it created?

At the time of events? Soon after? Much later? How might timing affect accuracy?

N
Nature — What type of source is it?

Official document? Personal letter? Newspaper? Photo? Each type has different reliability.

E
Evidence — What does it actually say?

What facts or claims does it make? What evidence supports these claims?

S
Standpoint — What perspective does it represent?

Whose viewpoint is this? What perspectives might be missing or silenced?

S
Significance — How useful is this source?

What can we learn from it? What are its limitations? How does it connect to other sources?

👥 Tool 3: Exploring Multiple Perspectives

NZ history events are often viewed very differently by different groups. For any event, consider:

🌿 Māori Perspective

How did tangata whenua experience this? What was the impact on iwi, hapū, whānau?

🏛️ Crown/Government Perspective

What was the official position? What were their stated reasons?

👥 Settler/Pākehā Perspective

How did European settlers view this? What were their interests?

🌏 Other Groups

Pacific peoples? Chinese gold miners? Women? Children? Workers?

Questions to ask:

  • Whose voices are loudest in the historical record? Why?
  • Whose voices are quiet or missing? Why might that be?
  • How do different perspectives help us understand the full picture?

📝 Tool 4: Investigation Worksheet

Topic I'm investigating:

Key question I want to answer:

Timeline Context

Before

What came before this event?

During

What happened?

After

What were the consequences?

Sources Used

Source 1:

Source 2:

Source 3:

My Conclusion

Based on my investigation, I conclude that:

👩‍🏫 Teacher Notes

Curriculum Alignment: NZC Level 4 Social Studies; Aotearoa New Zealand's Histories curriculum

Key Topics to Explore:

  • Te Tiriti o Waitangi / Treaty of Waitangi
  • New Zealand Wars / Ngā Pakanga o Aotearoa
  • Land confiscation and its effects
  • Women's suffrage movement
  • Immigration history
  • Māori Renaissance

Cultural Considerations: Be sensitive when discussing events that continue to affect communities today. Involve local iwi where possible.