Ethical Decision-Making (Tikanga in Action)

Critical Thinking Unit - Lesson 9 of 22 | Year 9-10 | Social Studies / Health

🌿 Whakataukī (Māori Proverb)

"Kia tika te kōrero, kia pono te mahi."

Meaning: Let your words be right and your actions be true.

Ethics is not just “what you think”. It is how you act — with integrity, care, and respect for people’s mana.

🎯 Learning Objectives

By the end of this lesson, you will be able to:

🧭 Starter: Values Line-Up (10 mins)

Students silently choose where they stand (Strongly agree → Strongly disagree) for a statement. Then discuss why — using evidence and care.

Statement 1

“If it’s legal, it’s ethical.”

Statement 2

“The best decision is the one that helps the most people.”

Statement 3

“Whose voice is missing matters more than what I think.”

Norm: You can change your mind — shifting is a sign of learning, not weakness.

🌿 Explore: A Tikanga Decision Path

Tika • Pono • Aroha

  1. Whose mana is involved? Who is most affected? Who must lead?
  2. What relationships are at stake? Whanaungatanga — what do we owe each other?
  3. What is tika? What is fair and just in this context?
  4. What is pono? What is true? What evidence do we have? What are we assuming?
  5. What is aroha? What is the caring response that reduces harm?
  6. What will we do? Choose an action and an accountability step.

Reminder: Sometimes the “best” option still has harm. Ethics includes honesty about trade-offs and working to reduce harm.

🏛️ Activity: Hui Simulation (25 mins)

Run a mini-hui to practise ethical decision-making with multiple stakeholders.

Scenario: Taonga Design & Consent

A school wants to use Māori designs on a sports uniform and in marketing. Students are excited — but no iwi/hapū have been consulted.

Roles (choose 4–6): tauira leaders, kaiako, principal, iwi/hapū representative (if appropriate), whānau, sponsor/company.

Task: Use the Tikanga Decision Path to reach a decision, then decide what accountability looks like (who to approach, how, what to change).

✅ Success Criteria

  • Names who holds authority and why
  • Uses evidence (not stereotypes) to justify decisions
  • Includes consent and relationship-building steps
  • Shows manaakitanga during discussion

🤔 Reflect & Connect (5 mins)

← Lesson 8: Evidence-Based Arguments Lesson 10: Capstone Showcase →