← Back to Handouts

Technology Definition Challenge

Questioning Colonial Assumptions About "Advanced" vs "Primitive"

The Problem with "Primitive" vs "Advanced"

How do we decide if something is "advanced technology" or "primitive tools"? Who gets to make that decision? This activity challenges you to think critically about how colonial perspectives have shaped what we consider "technological progress" - and why that matters for understanding pre-colonial Māori society.

Competing Definitions of Technology

Colonial Definition of "Advanced Technology"

  • Made of metal, not organic materials
  • Complex machinery with many moving parts
  • Powered by external energy sources
  • Mass-produced in factories
  • Generates profit and economic growth
  • Dominates or controls natural environment
  • Requires specialized experts to operate
  • Impressive to look at - shows human power
Question: Whose interests does this definition serve?

Indigenous Definition of "Advanced Technology"

  • Works effectively for its intended purpose
  • Uses sustainable, renewable materials
  • Can be maintained and repaired locally
  • Enhances community wellbeing and relationships
  • Respects and works with natural systems
  • Embeds cultural values and spiritual significance
  • Knowledge is shared and passed down through generations
  • Improves life while maintaining balance
Question: How would this definition change our view of pre-colonial societies?

Technology Evaluation Challenge

Use both definition systems to evaluate these technologies. Which definition makes more sense for each example?

🚗 Modern Car vs 🚤 Traditional Waka

Evaluation Criteria Car Waka
Effectiveness for transport ____/10 ____/10
Environmental sustainability ____/10 ____/10
Community self-reliance ____/10 ____/10
Cultural significance ____/10 ____/10
Durability and maintenance ____/10 ____/10

Which is more "advanced" and why?

💊 Modern Medicine vs 🌿 Rongoā Māori

Evaluation Criteria Modern Medicine Rongoā Māori
Effectiveness for healing ____/10 ____/10
Side effects and safety ____/10 ____/10
Accessibility to community ____/10 ____/10
Holistic approach to health ____/10 ____/10
Preventive vs reactive ____/10 ____/10

Which is more "advanced" and why?

🏭 Factory Farming vs 🌾 Traditional Māori Agriculture

Evaluation Criteria Factory Farming Traditional Agriculture
Food production volume ____/10 ____/10
Long-term sustainability ____/10 ____/10
Food quality and nutrition ____/10 ____/10
Environmental impact ____/10 ____/10
Community food security ____/10 ____/10

Which is more "advanced" and why?

Critical Analysis Questions

1. Bias in Technology Assessment

a) Why might colonial definitions of "advanced technology" ignore environmental sustainability?

b) How do colonial definitions justify taking land and resources from indigenous peoples?

c) Give an example of a "modern" technology that is actually less advanced than a traditional alternative:

2. Technology and Values

a) What values are embedded in Māori technology and innovation?

b) What values are embedded in colonial/industrial technology?

c) Which set of values do you think is more beneficial for humanity's future? Why?

3. Redefining Progress

a) If we used indigenous definitions of "advanced technology," how would this change our view of pre-colonial Māori society?

b) What would "technological progress" look like if it prioritized sustainability and community wellbeing?

c) How might this reframing change how we approach modern problems like climate change?

Creative Challenge: Design Your Definition

Create your own definition of "advanced technology" that incorporates the best aspects of both indigenous and modern thinking.

My Definition of Advanced Technology:

Advanced technology should be:

  1. _________________________________________________
  2. _________________________________________________
  3. _________________________________________________
  4. _________________________________________________
  5. _________________________________________________

Test Your Definition:

Using your definition, what would be the most "advanced" technology in today's world?

What current technology would you consider least "advanced" by your definition?

From Understanding to Action

How can this new understanding change how we think about technology and progress today?

🏫 In School

How could schools better recognize and teach about indigenous innovation?

🏘️ In Community

What traditional knowledge exists in your community that should be valued more highly?

🌍 In Society

How could society make better technology choices using indigenous principles?